If any lip liner stands out as the most iconic lip liner shade from the 90s it would be MAC Spice, and it’s back in demand again now. However, being a MAC product it’s on the expensive side so getting a MAC Spice liner dupe instead is an excellent idea.
To this day, MAC Spice is still extremely popular and shot into the spotlight again fairly recently when Kylie Jenner was reported to use it to line her lips.
MAC lip liners, including Spice, retail for $25 USD (or £20 / €26) for the full size pencil.
Fortunately you can get an amazing MAC Spice liner dupe for less money.
If you love MAC Spice but would like to find a more affordable dupe from a drugstore brand which is a fraction of the price, read on. MAC is also not a cruelty-free brand unfortunately. If finding a cruelty free dupe for MAC Spice is important to you, there are lots of options below.
These are the best dupes for MAC Spice lip liner.
Milani Color Statement Lip Liner in 09 Spice $6.49
The best MAC Spice dupe is often said to be Milani Cosmetics Color Statement Lip Liner in 09 Spice.
Compared to MAC products this is very inexpensive and pretty much the same exact shade.
Milani is a cruelty free brand, and this very affordable matte finish lip liner is also suitable for vegans making it the best dupe if you are avoiding brands that test on animals.
NYX Cosmetics Slim Lip Pencil in Natural $6
Another great cruelty free option is the NYX Slim Lip Pencil in Natural.
This is one of the most well known MAC Spice dupes, as it’s so similar to MAC’s Spice shade.
This NYX lip liner contains some really nice moisturizing ingredients like jojoba seed oil, coconut oil and shea butter that keep lips soft and give the liner itself a really creamy formula.
Maybelline Color Sensational Shaping Lip Liner in Totally Toffee $8.49
TikTok favorite lip liner Totally Toffee is also one of the best MAC Spice lip liner dupes of recent months.
In fact it became a best seller for Maybelline after several social media influencers showed how similar it is to the MAC lipliner.
Totally Toffee is a beautiful color with the same deep brown pink hue as Spice.
Kiko Milano Smart Fusion Lip Pencil in 532 Hazelnut $4.50
The color Hazelnut from Kiko is a pretty much perfect match for the MAC Cosmetics lip pencil in Spice.
Kiko is one of the most underrated drugstore brands in my opinion. They have some really good makeup products and they are completely cruelty free.
The KIKO Smart Fusion Lip Liner comes in a wide selection of different shades and is extremely affordable.
LA Girl Perfect Precision Lipliner in Sugar & Spice $4.00
This MAC Spice liner dupe is a great option if you’re really on a tight budget.
The difference between the MAC pencil and this one from LA Girl is so minimal that you really can hardly tell the difference, especially if you wear a lip gloss or lipstick over it.
It’s one of the best affordable MAC dupes out there and an excellent alternative from the drugstore.
Nabla Close-Up Lip Shaper in Nude #4 $12
Nude #4 from Nabla is a really good shade that is almost indistinguishable from Spice.
Nabla is an Italian brand but they do ship to the United States. They are also cruelty free and vegan-friendly as an added bonus.
LA Girl Ultimate Intense Stay Auto Lipliner in Keep It Spicy $5.49
Called ‘a subtle light brown’ by LA Girl, the shade Keep It Spicy is one of the most similar products out there to MAC Spice.
The slight difference between the two is that LA Girl’s lip pencil is a twist up product.
You can get really precise application with this fine-tipped liner though.
Barry M Lip Liner in 5 Russet $4
Barry M has a special place in my heart. 90s girls will remember the Dazzle Dust pots which are still going strong today.
They’re a cruelty free brand and in my opinion one of the most underrated and best brands in the drugstore.
Make sure to check out Russet by Barry M, as this is also an almost exact dupe for Spice. It is also easy to find if you live in the UK, and very affordable.
Rimmel Exaggerate Full Colour Lip Liner in Epic $6.99
Rimmel Exaggerate Lip Liner in Epic is also an almost perfect dupe if you can track it down.
Epic and Spice can be barely told apart when swatched next to each other.
Being such a universally flattering color, it’s no wonder MAC Spice lip liner has such a dedicated fan base.
It has a creamy texture and is the perfect mix of a medium-dark brown with an added pink shade.
You can use it just as a lip liner or to fill in your entire lips for a solid color. Top with some lip balm and you’re good to go.
Fortunately for us budget beauty fans, you can get that same pink cinnamon stick hue from this great dupe list for much less than the retail price of MAC’s lip pencils.
A MAC lip pencil is always a good choice but if you can get the same color and quality for less, it’s a no-brainer.
What color is MAC Spice lip liner?
MAC call this color a ‘pink cinnamon stick.’ In other words, it is a pinkish brown with slight orange undertones.
It is a warm tone and would work as a good nude lip liner for medium skin tones and darker skin tones.
On lighter skin tones it is still a great shade.
More dupes:
Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara dupe
Dupe for Glossier Stretch Concealer
Drunk Elephant bronzing drops dupe
Anywhere Caffeine lip liner dupe
DON’T MISS THIS:
Frequently asked questions
Before bringing out her own lip products, Kylie loved to wear MAC Spice. When the news came out that this was her go-to lip liner, it caused a huge rush in sales and Spice sold out almost instantly.
MAC Spice is a nice neutral to warm shade that goes with almost anything. It’s great to wear with nude lipsticks in particular; just make sure you pick a lipstick that matches your skin tone. You can also pair MAC Spice with a pink lipstick if you want to add a little more of a nude tone to it.
Lip liner is very versatile. A makeup artist would use it in various ways; you can just line the outer rim of your lips with it, or you can fill in your whole lip area for a long lasting color. Lip liner can also be smudged in from the outer edges for a gradient or ombre look.
This post contains affiliate links. A full disclosure is available from the main menu.
As a 90s girl, these colors were so flirtatious and fun! It’s exciting to see some of these shades coming back in popularity. I personally love and use anything with the subtle pink and red. Maybelline was my teen go-to makeup for everything lip liner dupes, eye shadows, mascara, and anything else I could put in my little Rite Aid basket.
90s girl here too! I loved Spice and it was so popular with all my friends as well.